Using mixpanel-browser, every time a non identified user refresh the page a new unique ID is assigned to that user. When the user is identified only the last assigned ID is merged. How I fix this?
Hi GastĂłn D., Please stand by as I search the Mixpanel knowledge base for an AI-powered answer. I normally take about 15 seconds or so. In case AI cannot answer your question, feel free to reach out to Mixpanel support at mixpanel.com/get-support. If you have follow-up questions for this thread, please tag me again with your question: @kapa.ai <follow-up question> đź‘‹
Feel free to ask a follow-up question once I've answered by mentioning me with @kapa.ai
Based on the information provided in the knowledge sources, it appears that you're experiencing an issue with user identification in Mixpanel using the browser SDK. To address this problem, I recommend the following approach: 1. Use $device_id for anonymous users:
Instead of relying on the automatically generated distinct_id for anonymous users, you should explicitly set a $device_id for anonymous events. This $device_id should persist across page refreshes.2. Call identify() when the user logs in:
When the user is identified (e.g., after logging in), call the identify() method with the user's known identifier.Here's how you can implement this: 1. For anonymous users: LBKS// Generate a persistent device ID (e.g., using a UUID library) const deviceId = generateUUID();LBKS// Store this deviceId in local storage or a cookieLBKS// For each event tracked while the user is anonymous: mixpanel.track('Event Name', { '$device_id': deviceId });LBKS2. When the user is identified: LBKS// User logs in mixpanel.identify('user_id');LBKS// Track events after identification mixpanel.track('Event Name', { '$device_id': deviceId, '$user_id': 'user_id' });LBKSBy following this approach, you ensure that all anonymous events are associated with the same $device_id, and when the user is identified, all these events will be merged with the identified user.This solution is based on the Simplified ID Merge system described in the Identifying Users (Simplified) documentation. It states that "When a $user_id and a $device_id is detected in the same event for the first time, it triggers a merge of the 2 IDs."Remember to call mixpanel.reset() when the user logs out to prevent unintentional merging of multiple users sharing one device.For more detailed information on implementing this approach, you can refer to the Mixpanel JavaScript SDK documentation.
kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
ℹ️ Tip: Mention @kapa.ai in the thread for follow-ups or DM the app for 1-to-1 help.
kapa.ai The thing is that MixPanel changes the $device_id when the page refresh
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! đź“š
I apologize for the confusion in my previous answer. You're correct that Mixpanel's behavior regarding the $device_id is different from what I initially described. Let's address this issue based on the actual behavior you're experiencing.The problem you're facing is that Mixpanel is generating a new $device_id on each page refresh for non-identified users. This is not the intended behavior, as it should persist across page refreshes. To fix this issue, we need to ensure that the $device_id remains consistent. Here's how you can address this: 1. Use localStorage or cookies to persist the $device_id:
Instead of relying on Mixpanel to manage the $device_id, you can generate and store it yourself using localStorage or cookies. This way, you can ensure it persists across page refreshes.2. Configure Mixpanel to use localStorage:
According to the Mixpanel JavaScript SDK documentation, you can configure Mixpanel to use localStorage instead of cookies, which might help with persistence: LBKSmixpanel.set_config({ persistence: "localStorage" });LBKS3. Manually set the $device_id on each track call:
After implementing steps 1 and 2, you should manually set the $device_id on each track call to ensure consistency: LBKS// Generate or retrieve the persistent device ID let deviceId = localStorage.getItem('mixpanel_device_id'); if (!deviceId) { deviceId = generateUUID(); // Use a UUID generation function localStorage.setItem('mixpanel_device_id', deviceId); }LBKS// Use this deviceId for all track calls mixpanel.track('Event Name', { '$device_id': deviceId });LBKS4. Identify the user when they log in:
When the user logs in, call the identify() method as usual: LBKSmixpanel.identify('user_id');LBKSBy implementing these steps, you should be able to maintain a consistent $device_id across page refreshes for non-identified users, and properly merge this data when the user is identified.If you continue to experience issues after implementing these solutions, I recommend reaching out to Mixpanel's support team for further assistance, as this behavior might be unexpected and could potentially be a bug in their SDK.
kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
ℹ️ Tip: Mention @kapa.ai in the thread for follow-ups or DM the app for 1-to-1 help.
kapa.ai instead set on every track, can I use alias or identify or register for the $device_id?
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! đź“š
Based on the knowledge sources provided and the context of your question, I can offer some guidance on using Mixpanel's methods to set the $device_id. However, the approach depends on which ID Merge system your Mixpanel project is using: Original or Simplified.For projects using the Simplified ID Merge system: You can use the register method to set the $device_id once, and it will be automatically included in subsequent events. Here's how you can do it: LBKS// Generate or retrieve the persistent device ID let deviceId = localStorage.getItem('mixpanel_device_id'); if (!deviceId) { deviceId = generateUUID(); // Use a UUID generation function localStorage.setItem('mixpanel_device_id', deviceId); }LBKS// Register the $device_id mixpanel.register({ "$device_id": deviceId });LBKSThis approach is supported by the Mixpanel JavaScript SDK documentation, which states: "If you have Simplified ID Merge enabled, send your event anonymous events with an anonymous ID set to the $device_id. Then call identify() while providing your chosen user ID once they are known (typically at registration and login)."For projects using the Original ID Merge system: The alias method is not recommended for setting the $device_id. Instead, you should use the identify method to link the anonymous ID to the user ID when the user is identified. Here's an example: LBKS// When the user is identified mixpanel.identify('USER_ID', 'ANON_ID');LBKSThis is supported by the Identifying Users (Original) documentation, which describes the $identify event used to link an Anonymous ID and your chosen User ID.In both cases, avoid using alias for setting the $device_id, as it's primarily used for legacy ID management and may not behave as expected in modern Mixpanel implementations.Remember to check which ID Merge system your project is using in your Project Settings to determine the best approach for your specific setup.
kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
ℹ️ Tip: Mention @kapa.ai in the thread for follow-ups or DM the app for 1-to-1 help.
kapa.ai this isn't working as expected import mixpanel from 'mixpanel-browser'; try { mixpanel.init(window.MIXPANEL_TOKEN, { debug: true, track_pageview: 'full-url', persistence: 'localStorage', loaded(mixpanel) { let deviceId = localStorage.getItem('mp_device_id'); if (!deviceId) { deviceId = mixpanel.get_distinct_id(); // Use a UUID generation function } localStorage.setItem('mp_device_id', deviceId); mixpanel.register({ $device_id: deviceId }); }, }); } catch (error) { console.log(error); } export const Mixpanel = mixpanel; $device_id isn't being registered on events while the localStorage is okay and is the same
Let me check the knowledge base for you again. One moment! đź“š
Based on the code you've provided and the issue you're experiencing, it seems that the $device_id is not being properly registered on events despite being set in localStorage. Let's analyze this and suggest a solution based on the Mixpanel documentation.The problem might be related to the timing of when you're registering the $device_id. The loaded callback in the init function might be executed after some events have already been tracked. To ensure that the $device_id is set before any events are tracked, we need to modify the approach slightly.Here's a revised version of your code that should work as expected: ```import mixpanel from 'mixpanel-browser';try {
// First, check if we have a deviceId in localStorage
let deviceId = localStorage.getItem('mp_device_id');
// Initialize Mixpanel with the persistence option
mixpanel.init(window.MIXPANEL_TOKEN, {
debug: true,
track_pageview: 'full-url',
persistence: 'localStorage'
});LBKS // If we don't have a deviceId, generate one
if (!deviceId) {
deviceId = mixpanel.get_distinct_id();
localStorage.setItem('mp_device_id', deviceId);
}LBKS // Register the $device_id
mixpanel.register({ "$device_id": deviceId });LBKS} catch (error) {
console.log(error);
}export const Mixpanel = mixpanel;LBKSLBKSThis approach ensures that the `$device_id` is set before any events are tracked. It's important to note that according to the [Mixpanel JavaScript SDK documentation](https://docs.mixpanel.com/docs/tracking-methods/sdks/javascript#managing-user-identity), for projects using Simplified ID Merge: LBKS"When using our Web or Mobile SDKs, Mixpanel will automatically generate an `$device_id` that's local to that user's device, and set that value as the `distinct_id` for the event. This ID will persist on all events tracked by that user on that device, until you call `identify()` or `reset()`."LBKSIf you're still experiencing issues after implementing this solution, it's possible that there might be a conflict with how Mixpanel is handling the `$device_id`. In this case, you might need to manually include the `$device_id` in each track call: LBKSLBKSmixpanel.track('Event Name', {
'$device_id': localStorage.getItem('mp_device_id')
});```If the problem persists, I recommend reaching out to Mixpanel's support team, as this behavior might indicate a potential issue with their SDK or your specific project configuration.Mixpanel JavaScript SDK documentation provides more details on managing user identity, which might be helpful in troubleshooting this issue further.
kapa.ai is still learning and improving, please let me know how I did by reacting below.
ℹ️ Tip: Mention @kapa.ai in the thread for follow-ups or DM the app for 1-to-1 help.